Noor, H., Salehpour Jam, A., Rajai, S. (2022). Comparison of effective factors on preventing participation of rural societies in watershed management plans based on local people and experts viewpoints. , 14(3), 400-411. doi: 10.22092/ijwmse.2021.127630.1713
Hamzeh Noor; Amin Salehpour Jam; Seyed Hossein Rajai. "Comparison of effective factors on preventing participation of rural societies in watershed management plans based on local people and experts viewpoints". , 14, 3, 2022, 400-411. doi: 10.22092/ijwmse.2021.127630.1713
Noor, H., Salehpour Jam, A., Rajai, S. (2022). 'Comparison of effective factors on preventing participation of rural societies in watershed management plans based on local people and experts viewpoints', , 14(3), pp. 400-411. doi: 10.22092/ijwmse.2021.127630.1713
Noor, H., Salehpour Jam, A., Rajai, S. Comparison of effective factors on preventing participation of rural societies in watershed management plans based on local people and experts viewpoints. , 2022; 14(3): 400-411. doi: 10.22092/ijwmse.2021.127630.1713

Comparison of effective factors on preventing participation of rural societies in watershed management plans based on local people and experts viewpoints

مهندسی و مدیریت آبخیز
Article 9, Volume 14, Issue 3, July 2022, Pages 400-411    PDF (922.02 K)
Document Type: Research Paper
DOI: 10.22092/ijwmse.2021.127630.1713
Authors
Hamzeh Noor* 1; Amin Salehpour Jam2; Seyed Hossein Rajai3
1Assistant Professor, Soil Conservation and Watershed Management Department, Khorasan Razavi Agricultural and Natural Resources Research Centre, Agricultural Research, Education and Extension Organization (AREEO), Mashhad, Iran
2Assistant Professor, Soil Conservation and Watershed Management Research Institute, Agricultural Research, Education and Extension Organization (AREEO), Tehran, Iran
3Researcher, Soil Conservation and Watershed Management Department, Agricultural and Natural Resources Research Center of Khorasan Razavi, Agricultural Research, Education and Extension Organization (AREEO), Mashhad, Iran
Abstract
The degree of public participation in watershed management programs is a major determinant of success or failure of the programs, but the factors which make people participate still remain unknown. The main objects of current study are comparison evaluation of effective factors on preventing participation of rural societies in watershed management plans based on all people and experts’ viewpoints in Emarat Watershed of Khorasan Razavi Province. In the current study the effective factors on preventing participation of rural societies were classify in four classes include "economic", "educational-extension", "design-executive" and "social" indicators and 14 sub-indicators. Then the indicators and sub-indicators were prioritized using Fuzzy Analytical Hierarchy Process and Friedman Test. Finally, the two-sample Kolmogrov–Smirnov Test was also used to examine the agreement of the two views on the importance of the items. The results showed that, from the perspective of both groups of experts and peoples, economic indicator has a greater role in preventing people participation in relation to other indicators. The results of sub-indicators prioritization based on local people and expert’s viewpoints showed that “ignoring people´s income as a direct economic motivation” and “shortage of education of watershed residents about plants and their purposes”, respectively, were ranked as the most important sub-indices. The most important difference of the sub-indices from the perspective of local people and expert are related to the “ignoring people´s income as a direct economic motivation” and “lack of stakeholder’s consultation in the design and development of projects”. The overall conclusion is that considering the benefits of stakeholders, and multi-purpose projects and factors such as stakeholder consultation, and training of local communities can provide the basis participation of people in the watershed development projects.
Keywords
Centralized decision-making power; Economic incentive; Fuzzy analytical hierarchy process; Multi-criteria decision making; Non-governmental organizations
References
  1. Ashoori, D., A. Bagheri, M.S. Allahyari and A. Michailidis. 2016. Understanding the attitudes and practices of paddy farmers for enhancing soil and water conservation in Northern Iran. International Soil and Water Conservation Research, 4(4): 260-266.‏
  2. Atmis, E.D.I., W. Lise and O. Yildiran. 2007. Factors affecting women’s participation in forestry in Turkey. Ecological Economics, 60(4): 787-796.
  3. Bagdi, G.L. and R.S. Kurothe. 2014. People’s participation in watershed management programmes: Evaluation study of Vidarbha region of Maharashtra in India. International Soil and Water Conservation Research, 2(3): 57-66.
  4. Bagherian, R., M. Goodarzi, A. Bagherian Kalat and M.J. Soltani. 2014. Factors influencing people’s participation in watershed management programs. Extension and Development of Watershed Management, 2(7): 21-28 (in Persian).
  5. Bagherian, R., M. Goodarzi, M. Sanaei Torqabah and A. Bagherian Kalat. 2017. Investigation on dimensions of people’s participation in watershed management programs; using factor analysis. Watershed Management Science and Engineering, 2(3): 1-10 (in Persian).
  6. Bagherian, R., B. Samah, A. Samah and S. Ahmad. 2009. A social exchange approach to people's participation in watershed management programs in Iran.‏ European Journal of Scientific Research, 3: 428-441.
  7. Elyasi, A., K. Shahedi and Sh. Rastgar. 2017. Effective factors on stakeholders’ willingness to participate at watershed management projects in Hezarkhani Watershed. Journal of Watershed Management Research, 8(16): 259-270 (in Persian).
  8. Garcia, X., M. Muro, A. Ribas, A. Llausàs, P. Jeffrey and D. Saurí. 2013. Attitudes and behaviors towards water conservation on the Mediterranean coast: the role of socio-demographic and place-attachment factors. Water International, 38(3): 283-296.
  9. Haidari, S.H. and S. Wright. 2001. Participation and participatory development among the Kalhor Nomads of Iran. Community Development Journal, 36(1): 53-62.
  10. Hematzadeh, Y. and N. Khalighi. 2006. Effective factors survey on lake of participation of users in pasture and watershed management design, case study: user of Kchik reagent sphere in Golestan Province. International Journal of Agricultural Sciences and Natural Resources, 13(4): 15-30 (in Persian).
  11. Liu, J., L. Yun, S. Liya, C. Zhiguo and B. Baoqian. 2010. Public participation in water resources management of Haihe River Basin, China: the analysis and evaluation of status quo. Procedia Environmental Sciences, 2: 1750-1758.‏
  12. Moghaddasi, N., V.B. Sheikh and A. Najafinejad. 2015. Qualitative evaluation of watershed management projects using descriptive-correlation method, case study: Boostan Dam Watershed. Water and Soil Conservation, 22(2): 205-217 (in Persian).
  13. Mohammadi Golrang, B., F.S. Lai and S.H.R Sadeghi. 2017. Evaluation of variables affecting people's participation in soil pasture and watershed management projects, case study: Kouskabad Watershed in Khorasan Razavi. Journal of Research and Rural Planning, 6(1): 49-68 (in Persian).
  14. Mosaffaie, J. and A. Salehpour Jam. 2020. Identification and prioritization of effective factors on preventing participation of rural societies in watershed management plans, case study: Niarij Watershed of Qazvin Province. Journal of Watershed Management Research, 11(22): 121-131 (in Persian).
  15. Mosaffaie, J. and A. Salehpour Jam. 2021. Prioritization of factors preventing participation of rural people in soil and water conservation projects (the case of Vers Watershed). Journal of Agricultural Science and Technology, 23(5): 975-986.
  16. Noor, H., R. Bagherian and R. Sedigh. 2018. Assessing attitudes of the rural populations of Khorasan Razavi Province to watershed management programs. Watershed Management Research Journal, 31(2): 17-26 (in Persian).
  17. Noor, H., M. Vafakhah and M. Mohammady. 2016. Comparison of different targeting methods for watershed management practices implementation in Taleghan Dam Watershed, Iran. Water Science and Technology: Water Supply, 17(5): 1316-1324.
  18. Rezaei, R., E. Vedadi and K. Mehrdoost. 2012. Studying the effective factors on participation of rural people in watershed plans of Khomarak Basin, case study: Deh Jalal Village. Rural Research, 3(9): 199-221 (in Persian).
  19. Salehpour Jam, A., J. Mosaffaie and M.R. Tabatabaei. 2021. Perspectives on barriers to people¢s participation in watershed management plans in south of Arad, the Ray County. Journal of Watershed Management Research, 34(2): 61-76 (in Persian).
  20. Salehpour Jam, A., A. Sarreshtehdari and M.R. Tabatabaei. 2018. Prioritizing preventing factors affecting on stakeholder's participation in watershed plans based on experts' idea, case study: watershed area surrounding city of Tehran. Journal of Watershed Engineering and Management, 9(4): 441-450 (in Persian).
  21. Shafiee, F., A. Rezvanfar, S.M. Hossini and F. Sarmadian. 2008. Opinion survey on soil conservation practices (the case study of Karkheh and Dez watershed's farmer's attitude, Khuzestan, Iran). Watershed Management Science and Engineering, 36: 69-75 (in Persian).
  22. Varua, M.E., B. Maheshwari, J. Ward and S. Dave. 2017. Groundwater conservation attitudes, behavior and water management: the case of farmers in rural India. Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, 220: 141-150.‏
Statistics
Article View: 580
PDF Download: 347


counter
Journal management system. designed by sinaweb